Review of CD with compositions by USTVOLSKAYA

Internet Edition compiled by Onno van Rijen

Updated 6 August 2000


Piano Sonata No. 3

Piano Sonata No. 5

In Combination with:
Webern: Variations opus 27
Silvestrov: Elegy
Boulez: 12 Notations

Ingrid Karlen (piano)

ECM New Series 449 936 2


Even the explicitly so-titled Webern piece needs to be understood not as variations on any particular theme, but as various ways of conceiving the whole notion of musical variations. As it happens this is the most successful of the Swiss pianist’s performances; she phrases expressively and seems to be aware of Peter Stadlen’s important facsimile edition containing the composer’s pencilled performance suggestions. She also gives a nicely gradated account of Silvestrov’s Elegy, whose lyrical 12-note idiom is more anonymous than his later style. Her comparatively low-pressure accounts of the Boulez Notations are no match for Pierre-Laurent Aimard’s, however. And she misses something of the fanatical intensity of Ustvolskaya’s sonatas (Ivan Sokolov’s, on Triton, are the best recordings currently available in the UK; for the absolute genuine article you have to hear Oleg Malov on MDC7876, only available direct from Megadisc Classics at Visserij 41, B-9000 Ghent, Belgium).

David J. Fanning
(From: Gramophone, July 1997)


Please send your comments

Return to Ustvolskaya Opus List

Return to Onno van Rijen's Soviet Composer's Page

Back to Onno van Rijen's Home Page